Wine Guide

How to Compare Two Wines Using Bottle Labels

Standing in the wine aisle with two unfamiliar bottles? The label holds more clues than you might expect. Learn what to compare and how a photo-based rating can help you choose.

← Back to the Compare plugin

What a Label Can Tell You

A wine label is not just branding. It identifies who made the wine, what grape it is made from, where it was grown, and when. Some labels also carry awards, critic scores, or a classification tied to the growing area. Used together, these details let you compare two bottles with more than a hunch.

Five Things to Compare

Producer

The winery's reputation is one of the strongest signals. A producer known for careful winemaking tends to be consistent from year to year.

Varietal

The grape type shapes the style. Match it to what you like and to what you will be eating.

Vintage

The year the grapes were harvested. Some wines are best young, others benefit from age, so consider the style as well as the number.

Region

Where the grapes grew influences flavor and quality. A specific appellation often signals a more defined style than a broad regional label.

Quality indicators

Medals, critic scores, and classification terms printed on the label give extra evidence. Treat them as one input, not the whole picture.

Side-by-Side Method

1

Photograph both labels

Take a clear picture of each bottle's front label. Include the producer, varietal, vintage, and region in frame.

2

Compare the clues

Note which bottle has the stronger producer, region, and quality indicators for your taste.

3

Check the rating

Use the Compare plugin to get a rating out of 5 for each bottle and a pick for the best one.

4

Decide

Weigh the rating against price, occasion, and your own preferences.

Using the Compare Plugin for Wine Bottles

In Compare, choose Wine bottles, then use Take a photo or Upload an image for Wine 1 and Wine 2. You can add up to five wines. Each bottle receives a rating from 1.0 to 5.0 on a Vivino-style scale with short notes, and when you add more than one bottle the best overall wine is marked with a trophy. If a label is unreadable, the notes say so and the rating is conservative.

Note: Ratings are based on what is visible on the label. They do not replace tasting. See wine ratings explained for how to read the score.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a label tell me if a wine is good?
It gives strong clues, such as producer, region, and any awards, but taste is personal and the label cannot capture everything.
How many wines can I add?
Up to five photos in one Wine bottles comparison.
What if I only have one bottle?
You still get a rating for that wine; the best-bottle trophy appears when you add more than one.
Does the plugin consider price?
Wine ratings are based on the label information. Compare price separately against the rating.
What if the label is faded or at an angle?
Retake the photo straight-on in good light. See how to take clear photos.

Related Guides